The actual services provided are the determining factor
Whether the service constitutes order execution, investment advice, or asset management depends on how the service is actually structured. The decisive factors are who makes the specific investment decision and whether the client must actively make a decision prior to each transaction. If transactions are automatically determined and executed without a new decision by the client, then classification as asset management is obvious. The fact that decision rules or ranges are established in advance does not change this. Passive and rule-based asset management also remain asset management. In our response, we ask the AFM to clarify the distinction between execution-only and individual asset management and to confirm that the scope of asset management remains intact.
No new intermediate category
A broader interpretation of “execution-only” must not result in a narrower scope for individual asset management. We ask the AFM to explicitly confirm this. In this regard, we refer to its 2021 sector letter on the scope of individual asset management and to the 2023 ESMA Supervisory Briefing on Copy Trading.
Comparison with Existing Fund Solutions
Profile funds, multi-asset funds, and life-cycle UCITS already provide a regulated framework for diversification, rebalancing, and risk reduction. That framework includes, among other things, rules for liquidity and risk management, an independent custodian, and pre-contractual and periodic product information. We ask the AFM to clarify what specific investor benefit automatic model portfolios within self-directed investing serve in addition to this. This question also applies to affordable digital investment advice and cost-efficient digital asset management.
Consistent across Europe
We advocate for a constructive, proportionate, and European-consistent approach, in line with the Retail Investment Strategy and the Savings and Investments Union. Innovation is welcome, but services that substantially have the characteristics of investment advice or asset management should not fall under a lighter execution-only regime.
